24-year old rookie Colt McCoy had a couple of rough games against the Ravens & Steelers the last two weeks of the year but overall he played well enough to likely enter 2011 as the Browns’ starting QB. McCoy was especially impressive when you consider the WRing corps he had to work with. One of the Browns’ top priorities this off-season will be upgrading at WR in both the draft and free agency. McCoy played in 8 games for the Browns as a rookie this year and he completed 135 of 222 passes (60.8%) for 1,576 yards with 6 TD passes and 9 INTs (74.5 QB Rating). McCoy also carried the ball 28 times for 136 yards (4.9 ypc) with 1 TD run as a rookie. McCoy will likely be a good fit in the Browns’ new West Coast Offense built on timing and rhythm.
30-year old Seneca Wallace will likely return as McCoy’s backup in 2011 due to the fact that he played pretty well last season and he knows the West Coast System pretty well from his time in Seattle. Wallace played in 6 games for the Browns last season and he completed 64 of 101 passes (63.4%) for 694 yards with 4 TD passes and 2 INTs (88.5 QB Rating). Wallace also carried the ball 7 times for 9 yards (1.3 avg) and he caught 1 pass for 9 yards. Wallace has now played in 54 games in his NFL career and he has completed 397 of 657 passes (60.4%) for 4,241 yards with 29 TD passes and 16 INTs (83.9 QB Rating). Wallace also has carried the ball 61 times for 223 yards (3.7 ypc) with 1 TD run and he has also caught 5 passes for 85 yards (17.0 avg) in his NFL career. Wallace is a solid backup and the Browns would be smart to bring him back.
The Browns are likely to part ways with 36-year old Jake Delhomme as he was pretty awful when healthy in 2010. Delhomme played in 5 games for the Browns this year and he completed 93 of 149 passes (62.4%) for 872 yards with 2 TD passes and 7 INTs (63.4 QB Rating). Delhomme has now played in 102 games (92 starts) in his NFL career and he has completed 1,723 of 2,904 passes (59.3%) for 20,764 yards with 125 TD passes and 101 INTs (81.2 QB Rating). Delhomme has also carried the ball 175 times for 328 yards (1.9 ypc) with 7 TD runs in this career to date. I look for the Browns to release Delhomme this off-season.
VERDICT: McCoy looks like he could be the Browns’ QB of both the future and the right now based on what I saw this year. But, the Browns are going to need to revamp the WRing corps to give him a fair shot. Seneca Wallace is a solid backup while Jake Delhomme looks like he’s toast.