Among the three hours of disgust I felt from noon to 3 p.m. watching the Browns lose 22-7 to the Buccaneers on Sunday, I also had a heavy heart as well. I knew that when the game was over, that I would never see Dennis Northcutt in an orange helmet in that stadium ever again.
Yes…call me crazy…I said I feel sad that Dennis Northcutt will never play another home game as a Brown.
Northcutt isn’t a very popular Brown - and I know many of you won’t have many kind words for him as he walks out the door into free agency at the end of the year. But, I for one, will miss him as a player on this team. Sure, he has dropped several key passes in his career as a Brown, and no he did not live up to his second round draft billing. However, Northcutt’s abilities as a punt returner are unquestioned - and I truly believe the Browns may struggle in finding the same consistency in a punt returner next season that they had in Northcutt. I feel that they will realize how valuable he was back there, and also realize that they took him for granted.
There is no need to take my word for it though. The numbers speak for themselves. This year Northcutt is in familiar territory - among the top 5 in the NFL in punt returns. He is currently third in punt return average at 11.1, trailing only Roscoe Parrish (11.7) and Devin Hester (13.3).
In 2005, Northcutt finished the year ranked 5th in the NFL in returns, averaging 10.5 yards per return. In 2004 he was third with a 12.0 average, and in 2002 he finished third again, with a career high 14.7 return average.
His only down season as a punt returner came in 2003 when he averaged only 8.2 yards per return and finished in the lower half of the league.
Consistent production like that is hard to find in the NFL - especially in an area such as punt returns - one of the more dangerous and volatile plays of the game.
So when this season is through (thank God), and Northcutt walks off the field for the last time as a Brown, it will be easy for us to remember his failure to become a dominant receiver. However, let’s not forget that as bad as he failed in that role…..he excelled just as well in another.
Punt returner could be the most important position fans take for granted on the football field, and with the consistency that Northcutt gave us at that position game in and game out, it was easy for us as Browns fans to do so.
Northcutt deserves our praise as knowledgeable fans for the job he has done as a Brown punt returner. His body of work as a returner is impressive, and one of the few positives statistics that we have seen from this franchise since it’s return in 1999.
How many positive stats can the Browns say they have been consistently ranked in the top 5 of the league over the past 8 seasons?
One. Punt return average…thanks to Northcutt.
I just hope next Sunday in Houston he breaks one the distance…so we can appreciate him in that role one last time.